What we were taught as teachers, and what I know now.

Perhaps things are now different as it’s some time since I was teaching in the classroom. But, in my experience, as teachers we were taught many things, sometimes explicitly and sometimes more implicitly, which I now realise were wrong. I have found this since leaving school teaching, finding my own route through the world, having two children with developing neurodiverse needs, and dealing with thousands of learners, young and old, who don’t subscribe to what we were taught as teachers.

Here I would like to discuss some of what I was taught - deliberately or incidentally - that I have since learned to challenge. The “lessons” do not reflect my own beliefs then or now, but they do reflect the opinions, general or specific, of those who have or had influence over other teachers.

We were taught, for example, that autistic children - who are mainly boys don't you know - will avoid eye contact, that they struggle to understand emotions, and that they might need help understanding things. In many cases, they will have a TA and might well have some fun special skills. I think back to one of my students that could be given a place, a date and a time and could tell you what trains to catch to get there, at what time, where to change, and make a fair prediction of the type of engine that would be used. His twin brother spent most of his life print screening the M1 from Google StreetView into PowerPoint so he could turn driving up the motorway into a movie. 

There are now theories that the emotional detecting goes both ways - an autistic learner may not be able to detect your emotions accurately but equally you may not be able to detect theirs. Who really has the problem? Those autistic children, by the way, are just as likely to be girls, but girls tend to hide behind a mask. The special interests may be real, and may be cool, they may be also one of the most important things in their lives and you turning it into a joke or laughing about it can be like a stab to the heart. Planning your lessons around it can bring it to the attention of all - and it only takes one cruel child…

We were taught that any sort of condition that was assessed through private means was probably a foregone conclusion because parents were paying, and therefore the assessor was bound to diagnose - you don’t disappoint the pay-check. Therefore, we had to play nice in public but, in general, we could assume it was either not a real diagnosis or not as severe as the parent was making out.

Having a diagnosis of autism can actually hinder you in later life. There are stories of problems - both physical or mental - being blamed on autism that may well have other factors or causes. One way of avoiding this is to go for a private diagnosis and requesting the result is not communicated with the NHS. A more common reason for private diagnoses, be it for autism or other neurological differences, is quite simply the impossibility of any other route. A wait of 4+ years to be seen by CAMHS (Child and Adult Mental Health Services) is not just "not unknown" - it is the good side of normal in many areas. That is to be seen, not to receive a diagnosis or any support. And many neurological condition are not supported by CAMHS at which point you are often left to fend for yourself as an individual or family. Is it surprising that so many families now scrimp, save, or borrow money for a private assessment which leads to a diagnosis.

We were taught that black African boys, in particular, are horrendously badly behaved at school because they receive such strict punishment at home that school is the only place it can come out. In some cases this is true; I’ve had to physically restrain a black African child that was self harming through fear of his mother finding out about some relatively minor behavioural issue. A colleague ended up giving evidence in court after his mother threw a shoe at him across the classroom during parents evening. But I’ve also known black African families which are incredibly loving, and some who are middle of the road, where discipline at home is lax, and where discipline at home is perfectly normal. Equally I’ve known families from all other races, religions, colours, backgrounds, heritages, that would not differ from the black African boy smashing his head against the wall other than we didn’t label it as a problem due to their race. We can end up in a self-fulfilling cycle. As teachers we of course have to be aware of problems that our students may face - because some of them face horrible things - but we need to delink this from preconceptions. This, by the way, was an explicit teaching!

We were taught that results are everything. Missing a day of school is a disaster. I calculated some years ago that GCSE students sit an average of something like 27 hours of exams. Most students site 2-3 round of mock exams so 100 hour of formal assessment is not unrealistic. Wow. And for most students the outcome of that is simply to get you into sixth form. Which… you can normally get into with English and Maths at a C grade (4-5 in new money) and a grade B (grade 6) in your chosen A-level subjects, with the grades needed for less academic destinations (colleges, BTECs, apprenticeships) dropping down from there. 

So why are we chasing the top grades? Your A-level results impact you getting into Uni so chasing them matters, but when have we ever really needed an A-grade in GCSE Geography? When have we needed eight subjects? I’ll tell you why. Because we take those eight subjects, and as long as they’re the right mix, maths double-counts and (if you’ve one lang and lit) your best English grade double counts to give you ten. You take all your number grades and add them up, then divide by ten to get your attainment eight grade with an average of 7.8 being better than 7.7. Then you are compared against all the other students in the country that got the same SAT scores as you at the age of 11 (five years before!) and if you are above the average you have a positive progress eight, if you are under the average you have a negative progress eight. Zero is bang on average. And the school mashes these all together to get their progress eight score. And if their progress eight score is not good enough the government, Ofsted, and these days the CEO of their multi-academy trust shouts at them and puts them under the cosh for observation. So we put our young people through all these exams and drive them to get the highest scores so we don’t get shouted at. I’ve managed to get four degrees, have taught to post-graduate level, and have only ever had a to prove I had Maths, English and Science GCSEs at C-grade (or equivalent). Academies (which make up 83% of secondary schools) don't actually have to do GCSEs - some iGCSEs for example are much more accessible - but they don't fit into the league tables and they are held accountable for them. Which matters to nobody but the school and the government.

We were taught that uniform is important. It grants a sense of community and pride. It stops bullying because some students cannot afford the latest nicest name brands. In some cases this is true. In some cases. I worked with a school in the US who (like most) have zero uniform requirements other than you cannot be indecent. They had some bullying about the clothes students wore. But their overall levels of bullying were no worse than UK schools - it’s not all like we see on TV with every dweebie kid getting swirlies - all this suggests is that kids will find some way of bullying each other. Incidentally I've dealt with issues of bullying where blazers have been too big (because parents buy them to last) and too small (because they're so expensive to replace). Over the years the DfE have tried to reduce the amount of branded clothes that form part of uniform, but I’m sat in a school at the moment where most kids are wearing branded PE tops, branded PE trousers or shorts, and those in uniform are wearing white shirts, branded ties, jumpers, branded blazers, and smart trousers. Does the DfE somehow think that blue shorts with 2” white stripes , or royal blue blazers are significantly cheaper without branding when you bear in mind that the shorts or blazer still have to be bought (often only available from limited places due to the designs) and, without uniform requirements, would not. Until they stop grown children don’t generally wear out clothes, they grow out of them, so uniform is an expense that would not otherwise need to be born, and has zero use outside of school. Dark blue jeans can be worn for pleasure or school - as can a plain t-shirt. Both of which I’m wearing right now. Why does this upset me so much? I had a student some years ago I was asked to prepare permanent exclusion paperwork for. When I tracked back, every single incident on his record linked back to a starting point of uniform. Not wearing shoes (he has huge feet and found school shoes uncomfortable), not wearing a tie (he had a neurological condition and found done-up buttons and ties irritating). Yes, these escalated because he also had zero impulse control, due to a Tourette's and ADHD diagnosis which wasn’t real… because it came from a private diagnosis. The students I now work with have no uniform yet make exceptional progress. Realistically, it’s power. Minions wear uniform, those with power control their own dress.

We were taught that elective home schooling is primarily when parents think they know better than the school and yank their kids out due to some disagreement or other, or is something we can nudge parents towards when their kids can't behave properly. COVID had a huge impact on home schooling, but other things have really opened my eyes more to it as well. Our own eldest daughter now learns at home, despite being in year 11. She is autistic, and has just not been able to cope with the noise, pressure, intensity of being in school. To be transparent, the school have been brilliant. She was offered a quiet room to work in and was going to just one lesson a day, in her room alone apart from that, but even this was too much. The school have kept her on role, she is sitting (with difficulty) her mocks there, and will sit her final exams there. But this is a rare thing. Our other daughter has a complex mix of neurological condition and while some support is offered in school, she is not allowed to access all of it until key stage 4 and some teachers just blindly refuse to acknowledge her needs. She would benefit from home schooling in many ways, but due to her focussing challenges would need 1:1 support throughout. Neither of us can afford this amount of time and of course there is zero financial support for parents that home educate.

My eyes have been opened further by the work I do with Wolsey Hall Oxford; we support elective home-educated students from across the world. Some are professional or trying to become professional sports-people, some families travel a lot (with work or for pleasure), but many mirror the lives of my own children, yet the majority do incredibly well under Wolsey Hall. So what I've learnt is true is that many parents do know better.

This post was not meant to be a 2,000 rant, so perhaps I'll draw it to a close here. What I have mentioned is merely the most obvious tip of the iceberg, those things that occurred to me while supporting a new teacher in a secondary school. There are many more. Perhaps one day there will be a part two.